The Science of Successful New Year’s Resolutions

by Jon Scaccia January 1, 2025

Today, millions of people commit to life-changing goals. Whether it’s hitting the gym, quitting smoking, or simply drinking more water, the new year offers a “fresh-start effect,” inspiring hope and motivation. But what separates those who achieve their resolutions from those who abandon them by February? A recent large-scale study might have the answers, revealing key strategies to turn resolutions into lasting habits.

What Makes Resolutions Stick?

Scientists from Stockholm University conducted a groundbreaking study with over 1,000 participants, exploring the dynamics of New Year’s resolutions. The goals ranged from physical health and weight loss to personal growth and improved relationships. Remarkably, 55% of participants considered themselves successful after one year—a higher rate than seen in many past studies.

The research uncovered several critical factors that influence success:

• Goal Orientation: Resolutions framed as approach-oriented (e.g., “I will eat more vegetables”) were more successful (58.9%) than those phrased as avoidance-oriented (e.g., “I will stop eating junk food”), which had a 47.1% success rate.
• Support Systems: Participants who received “some support”—including advice on goal setting and periodic follow-ups—outperformed both those who had no support and those who received extensive, detailed guidance.

The Power of Approach-Oriented Goals

Why do approach-oriented goals lead to greater success? Imagine you’re setting out on a journey. If you focus on moving toward a destination (“I’ll walk 10,000 steps daily”), every step feels like progress. But if your mindset centers on avoiding pitfalls (“I’ll stop being lazy”), the journey can feel like dodging endless obstacles.

Approach-oriented goals create a sense of positive momentum, making success more tangible. They also shift your focus to building new habits rather than obsessing over breaking old ones. Instead of fixating on what not to do, you’re actively creating change.

Support: The Right Amount Matters

Participants in the study were divided into three groups:

1. No Support: These individuals simply recorded their resolutions and periodically reported progress.
2. Some Support: This group received additional guidance, including reminders and simple exercises to overcome obstacles.
3. Extended Support: Along with everything the second group received, this group was coached on SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Time-bound) and interim benchmarks.

Surprisingly, the second group—those with moderate support—had the highest success rates. Why didn’t the extended support group perform better? One theory suggests that overly detailed instructions may lead to feelings of failure when every specific milestone isn’t met. By contrast, simpler guidance allows for flexibility and reduces the pressure to achieve perfection.

Lessons for Your Next Resolution

The study offers valuable insights for anyone eager to make meaningful changes. Here’s how you can apply these findings to your own resolutions:

1. Set Approach-Oriented Goals

• Focus on what you want to achieve rather than what you want to avoid.
• Examples:
  • Approach: “I will save $50 every week.”
  • Avoidance: “I will stop wasting money.”

2. Seek Some Support

• Share your goals with a friend or family member who can hold you accountable.
• Use tools like goal-tracking apps or join online communities for encouragement.

3. Simplify Your Plan

• While SMART goals are effective, avoid overwhelming yourself with overly rigid benchmarks.
• Be flexible and celebrate small wins along the way.

4. Track Progress Over Time

• Periodic check-ins can reinforce commitment and help you adjust strategies as needed.
• Reflect on your successes and challenges to stay motivated.

Beyond the Resolution: Why It Matters

New Year’s resolutions aren’t just about individual growth—they’re a window into human behavior. Understanding what drives successful change can inform broader strategies in education, workplace productivity, and even public health initiatives. For instance, the principles of approach-oriented goals and moderate support could be applied to encourage healthier lifestyles or improve team dynamics.

But perhaps the most profound takeaway is this: meaningful change is possible. With the right mindset and tools, resolutions can evolve from fleeting aspirations into life-altering achievements.

Let’s Explore Together

Now it’s your turn! Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments or on social media. Here are a few questions to spark discussion:

• Have you ever set a New Year’s resolution that stuck? What made it successful?
• How do you think approach-oriented goals could change the way you tackle challenges?
• What type of support do you find most helpful when pursuing personal goals?

Let’s keep the conversation going and inspire each other to reach new heights. Here’s to a year of growth, discovery, and success!

Be Part of the Change – Get Weekly Updates!

Stay informed and connected. Subscribe for free and share this blog to make a difference in public health with others. If you liked this blog, please share it! Your referrals help This Week in Public Health reach new readers.