Tracing the Hidden Pathways of Concealed Gun Carrying Across a Lifetime

by Jon Scaccia January 6, 2025

The patterns of concealed gun carrying reveal starkly different stories depending on whether someone starts carrying in their teenage years or as an adult. These differences don’t just shape individual lives—they echo through our communities and influence the very fabric of public safety. This blog unpacks groundbreaking research that follows concealed gun carrying across a lifetime, offering fresh insights into the behaviors, motivations, and societal shifts behind this phenomenon.

Adolescence vs. Adulthood: Two Pathways Diverge

The research uncovers a “dual pathway” model of concealed gun carrying. Adolescents who carry are often reacting to immediate, tangible threats—having witnessed or experienced gun violence firsthand. In contrast, adults who begin carrying later in life are motivated by broader perceptions of danger, societal instability, or the need for personal protection. Let’s delve deeper into these pathways.

Adolescent-Onset Carrying

• Age-Limited Behavior: Most teens who carry guns stop doing so as they transition to adulthood.
• Key Predictors: Direct exposure to gun violence, such as witnessing shootings, often triggers this behavior.
• Connection to Violence: Adolescents who carry are more likely to use guns during their teenage years, although this rarely extends into adulthood.

Adult-Onset Carrying

• Persistent Behavior: Adults who begin carrying after age 21 are far more likely to continue carrying throughout their lives.
• Broader Motivations: Unlike teens, adults often cite diffuse fears, such as societal instability, as their reason for carrying a firearm.
• Rising Trends: Adult carrying has surged in recent years, especially following events like the COVID-19 pandemic and heightened social unrest.

The Ripple Effects of Societal Change

This study spans over 25 years of data from Chicago neighborhoods, capturing how historical events reshape concealed gun carrying. Two periods stand out:

1. 2016: A rise in concealed carrying coincides with political polarization and increased firearm accessibility.
2. 2020-2021: A dramatic spike in gun purchases and carrying followed the pandemic and protests against police violence.

These surges suggest that societal instability doesn’t just affect crime rates—it profoundly influences individual decisions about personal safety and gun ownership.

What the Data Tells Us

Here are some fascinating findings:

• Prevalence: By age 40, nearly 32% of study participants had carried a concealed gun at some point in their lives.
• Demographics: Men are three times more likely than women to carry a gun, and racial disparities persist, with higher rates of carrying among Black and Hispanic individuals compared to white individuals.
• Legal vs. Illegal Carrying: Adolescent-onset carrying is almost always illegal, while adult-onset carrying often follows the easing of state gun laws.

These statistics illuminate the complex interplay between individual behaviors, societal norms, and legislative changes.

Implications for Policy and Public Safety

Understanding these pathways has profound implications:

• Targeted Interventions: Efforts to reduce gun violence among adolescents should focus on mitigating direct exposure to gun violence.
• Policy Focus: For adults, addressing perceptions of societal instability and promoting responsible gun ownership could be more effective.
• Long-Term Impact: Policies that regulate concealed carry may influence not just immediate crime rates but also long-term patterns of gun use across generations.

Broader Questions: Why It Matters

This research doesn’t just detail who carries a gun and when—it raises bigger questions:

• How do societal perceptions of safety and danger evolve over time?
• What role does community support play in preventing adolescent gun carrying?
• Can public policy effectively address the psychological and cultural factors driving adult gun ownership?

These questions invite us to think deeply about how personal choices intersect with broader societal forces.

Let’s Explore Together

What do you think about these findings? Here are some questions to spark discussion:

1. How do societal events, like the pandemic, influence individual behaviors around safety and protection?
2. What policies do you think could effectively reduce the risks associated with concealed gun carrying?
3. How might community-based programs help prevent adolescent gun carrying?

Share your thoughts in the comments or join the conversation on social media. Let’s continue exploring this complex and vital topic together.

Conclusion:

The story of concealed gun carrying is more than just numbers—it reflects our society’s fears, values, and challenges. By understanding these pathways, we gain insights into how to create safer communities and foster a culture of responsible firearm ownership. The journey from adolescence to adulthood, as seen through the lens of concealed gun carrying, offers lessons that are as personal as they are profound.

Transform Your Science World

Get the latest and most inspiring scientific updates with ‘This Week in Science’! Perfect for educators and science enthusiasts, our free weekly newsletter delivers groundbreaking research and stories that ignite your passion for learning and teaching. Sign up today and transform your approach to science. If you liked this blog, please share it! Your referrals help This Week in Science reach new readers.