Welcome to the Wild World of Online Conspiracy Culture (It’s Not What You Expect)

by Jon Scaccia May 5, 2025

What if I told you that not everyone swapping conspiracy theories online actually believes them? And that a huge chunk of Reddit’s infamous r/conspiracy forum treats wild ideas like a mix between debate club, improv night, and serious investigation?

Buckle up, because a new study just flipped the script on what we thought we knew about conspiracy culture.

First Things First: It’s Not an Echo Chamber

We’ve all heard the warnings: social media creates “echo chambers” where conspiracy theories spiral out of control. But when researchers spent six months lurking on r/conspiracy (yes, six months of deep Reddit immersion), they found something surprising:

r/conspiracy isn’t a cult of radical believers. It’s a messy, hilarious, sometimes brilliant battle royale of believers, doubters, skeptics, trolls, and… well, people who just want to have fun.

Only 0.335% of the subreddit’s 1.9 million members actually post or comment. Everyone else? They’re mostly reading, upvoting, and side-eyeing the chaos.

Conspiracy Topics: From Aliens to Weather Control

The top 5 favorite topics? Grab your bingo cards:

• COVID vaccines and virus theories
• School shootings
• Aliens and UFOs
• Climate change conspiracies
• 9/11 alternative theories

But it doesn’t stop there. Flat Earth? Check. Secret lizard overlords? Double check. Chemtrails, JFK, moon landing hoaxes? It’s like the greatest hits album of “Questionable Thoughts.”

Meet the Players: Believers, Doubters, and Jokers

So who’s hanging out in this online tinfoil hat convention? It turns out, there are three main mindsets:

1. The Believers: “Trust No One”

Some users are genuinely convinced that hidden forces control the world. But even among them, there’s drama:

“Talking about lizard people discredits real conspiracies!”

Believers constantly fight each other over which theories are “serious” and which are “stupid.” It’s less “one big club” and more “a hundred tiny clubs throwing shade.”

2. The Doubters: “Question Everything (Including You)”

Then you’ve got the skeptics. They don’t fully believe any theory, but they doubt everything the “mainstream” says. Think X-Files’ Mulder—but a little more exhausted.

“There is no ‘we’ here. Just a space to question and think.”

These folks treat conspiracy theories like riddles to solve, not gospels to follow.

3. The Playful Tricksters: “It’s Just for Fun, Chill”

Believe it or not, a big slice of r/conspiracy just wants to play. They swap theories like campfire ghost stories:

“We like thinking the elite are lizards. It’s FUN.”

For them, conspiracy theories are entertainment, not ideology. They’re here for the wild ride—Bigfoot, UFOs, secret bunkers—not for political revolutions.

Plot Twist: Doubt and Play Are As Common As Belief

Here’s the mind-blowing part:

r/conspiracy isn’t brainwashing people. It’s constantly debating, mocking, and playing with ideas. People doubt each other’s theories as much as they doubt the “official story.”

Some even think the craziest posts are planted by trolls or bots to make the community look bad! (Meta-conspiracy: unlocked.)

Why This Matters (More Than You Think)

Sure, conspiracy theories can be dangerous. But treating everyone who talks about them as a radical extremist? That’s just wrong.

This research shows that:

• Conspiracy culture is way more diverse than we thought.
• Most people are dipping in and out of these theories, not diving headfirst.
• Playfulness and doubt are huge parts of the conversation.

Understanding this complexity matters — especially when we’re trying to tackle misinformation in smart, effective ways.

So, What’s Next?

Maybe we need to rethink how we talk about conspiracy culture. It’s not just about shutting things down. It’s about understanding why people are drawn to these stories in the first place—sometimes for meaning, sometimes for fun, and sometimes just to question the world a little more.

Let’s Explore Together!

What do you think?

• Would you ever dive into a conspiracy theory just for fun?
• What’s the wildest theory you’ve ever heard (or believed)?
• How do you think we should handle conspiracy talk in today’s world?

Drop your thoughts below, share with your most curious friends, and keep questioning—but maybe keep the lizard people jokes to a minimum (unless you’re really good at them).

Science Needs Champions—Be One

In a world where science is politicized and facts are under siege, your voice—and your knowledge—matter. This Week in Science equips teachers, learners, and advocates with the latest research, bold discoveries, and big ideas shaping our future.
This free weekly newsletter helps you speak up with confidence, teach with impact, and lead with facts.
Subscribe today and stand with science when it needs you most.